Garvee 54" x 39" Universal vs Garvee 51x36 in Roof Basket: Spec Comparison
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Links on this page are affiliate links.
When comparing the garvee 54 x 39 universal vs 51x36 in roof basket, you see two steel cargo carriers with identical 200 lb load capacities. Both include a 15 cubic foot roof bag and feature powder-coated rust resistance. The main difference lies in their footprint. The 54-inch model offers a larger base area, while the 51-inch version provides a more compact profile. Both sit at 5 inches high and weigh 40 pounds, making them suitable for SUVs and trucks with crossbars.
Key differences
| Aspect | Garvee 54x39 Roof Rack Basket | Garvee 51x36 in Roof Basket |
|---|---|---|
| Basket Dimensions | 54" L x 39" W x 5" H | 51" L x 36" W x 5" H |
| Model Number | PAE_347 | PAU_0L2 |
| Color Options | Classic | Black |
| Bag Dimensions | Not listed | 44" x 34" x 17" |
| Weight | 40 pounds | 40 pounds |
Which one should you choose?
Choose Garvee 54x39 Roof Rack Basket if
- You need the maximum possible base area for wide or bulky items on your roof rack.
- You prefer the Classic color finish for your cargo carrier setup.
- You want a model that explicitly lists configurable size options in its features.
Choose Garvee 51x36 in Roof Basket if
- You have a smaller roof rack or crossbar setup where a compact footprint is necessary.
- You prefer the Black color finish for your cargo carrier setup.
- You want specific dimensions for the included soft-shell luggage bag.
Verdict: Choose the 54-inch model if your vehicle can accommodate the larger footprint and you prioritize maximum base area. Select the 51-inch model if you need a more compact solution that fits tighter roof rack configurations. Both offer identical load capacity and durability features for your gear.
Garvee 54x39 vs 51x36 Basket
basket footprint
The Garvee 54x39 Roof Rack Basket measures 54 inches in length and 39 inches in width. This larger surface area provides more room for bulky items like luggage or camping gear. The Garvee 51x36 in Roof Basket is slightly smaller, with dimensions of 51 inches by 36 inches. The difference is three inches in length and three inches in width. You need to check your vehicle's roof space to see which fits better. The larger basket offers more total storage area for your cargo. The smaller basket may fit vehicles with tighter crossbar spacing. Both baskets share the same height of five inches. Choose the size that matches your roof dimensions and cargo needs.
load capacity
Both cargo carriers support a maximum load of 200 pounds. The Garvee 54x39 Roof Rack Basket lists a 200 lb capacity in its features. The Garvee 51x36 in Roof Basket also specifies a 200 lb weight limit. This identical rating means both can carry heavy loads like roof boxes or large bags. You do not lose carrying power by choosing the smaller basket. The steel construction supports this weight on both models. Ensure your vehicle's roof rack can also handle 200 pounds. Distribute the weight evenly across the basket floor. Both baskets are built to secure heavy items during travel. The load capacity remains the same regardless of the footprint size.
included roof bag
Both models include a soft-shell roof bag with 15 cubic feet of storage. The Garvee 54x39 Roof Rack Basket comes with this additional bag for extra space. The Garvee 51x36 in Roof Basket also provides a 15 cubic foot bag. The bag for the smaller basket measures 44 inches by 34 inches by 17 inches. This extra storage helps when the basket is full or when you need to transport soft items. The bags are waterproof and UV resistant. They feature multi-layer reinforced seams for durability. Reflective strips on the bags enhance visibility at night. You get the same bonus storage volume with either basket choice.
weight
Both baskets weigh exactly 40 pounds. The specifications for the Garvee 54x39 Roof Rack Basket list a weight of 40 pounds. The Garvee 51x36 in Roof Basket also weighs 40 pounds. This identical weight means neither basket adds more load to your vehicle's roof. You can install either one without worrying about extra weight affecting fuel economy. The steel construction contributes to this substantial weight. The weight is distributed across the basket frame. You need to ensure your roof crossbars can support the basket weight plus the cargo. The load capacity and basket weight are the same for both models.
build materials
Both baskets use steel construction with a matte black powder coat. The Garvee 54x39 Roof Rack Basket features a powder-coated finish that resists rust and scratches. The Garvee 51x36 in Roof Basket uses powder-coated steel and electrophoretic technology for corrosion resistance. Both designs include metal bars at the bottom and side rails for secure transport. They also feature a steel wind deflector to reduce drag. The reflective strips on the bags aid in nighttime safety. The build quality focuses on durability and weather resistance. You get similar protective coatings on both models to withstand outdoor conditions.
Which Garvee Roof Basket Fits You
Owner of wide SUVs or trucks
You need the larger 54 by 39 inch footprint to maximize cargo space. This model offers a wider surface area for bulky gear. The extra length and width accommodate more items securely. You get the same 200 lb capacity as the smaller version, but with significantly more room to spread out your load.
Driver of narrower crossbars
This 51 by 36 inch basket fits vehicles with narrower roof racks better. The reduced footprint prevents overhang on smaller cars. It still holds 200 lbs and includes the same 15 cubic foot roof bag. You save space on the roof while maintaining high load capacity and durability for your trips.
Seeking compact storage solution
You want a lighter, smaller carrier that does not dominate your vehicle. This model is more compact than the 54 inch option. It retains the 200 lb weight limit and includes the waterproof roof bag. The smaller dimensions make it easier to store when not in use and less obstructive on the road.
The products compared
Garvee 54x39 Roof Rack Basket
Best for: Large cargo loads with extra bag space
- Mount Type
- Roof-mount (crossbars)
- Weight Capacity
- 200 lbs
- Basket Dimensions
- 54" x 39" x 5"
- Material
- Steel
- Side Rail Height
- 5 inches
- Load Capacity
- 200 lb
View on Amazon: Garvee 54x39 Roof Rack Basket Affiliate link
This Garvee roof basket measures 54 inches by 39 inches and supports up to 200 pounds. It weighs 40 pounds and stands 5 inches high. The design includes a 15 cubic foot soft-shell cargo bag for extra storage. You can install it on crossbars using universal U-bolts. The powder-coated steel resists rust and scratches. This setup suits you if you need a large, secure base for long trips.
Pros
- 200-pound load capacity
- Includes 15 cubic foot cargo bag
- Adjustable to 39x39 inch configuration
- Matte black powder coating for rust resistance
Cons
- 40-pound weight adds roof load
- Requires existing crossbars for mounting
- No integrated locking mechanism mentioned
Good fit if
- You need maximum cargo space
- You already have roof crossbars
- You transport bulky outdoor gear
Skip if
- You have narrow roof rails
- You want a lightweight solution
- You lack crossbars for mounting
Verdict: Garvee 54x39 Roof Rack Basket offers high capacity and extra bag storage for large loads. It fits you if you prioritize volume over minimal weight.
Garvee 51x36 in Roof Basket
Best for: narrower roof racks needing waterproof storage
- Mount Type
- roof-mount
- Weight Capacity
- 200 lb
- Basket Dimensions
- 51 x 36 x 5 in
- Material
- steel
- Vehicle Type
- SUV, Truck
- Dimensions
- 51 × 36 × 5 inches
View on Amazon: Garvee 51x36 in Roof Basket Affiliate link
This Garvee roof basket measures 51 by 36 inches with a 200-pound load capacity. It weighs 40 pounds and offers 15 cubic feet of storage. The steel construction features a powder-coated finish for rust resistance. A soft-shell bag provides waterproof protection for your cargo. It includes a wind deflector and reflective stickers for safety. This setup suits SUVs and trucks needing reliable rooftop storage.
Pros
- 200 lb weight capacity
- 15 cubic feet storage volume
- Powder-coated steel construction
- Includes wind deflector fairing
- Waterproof soft-shell bag included
Cons
- 51-inch length is shorter than the 54-inch competitor
- 36-inch width is narrower than the 39-inch competitor
- Requires manual assembly of the bag and basket
Good fit if
- You need a 200 lb load limit
- You want a smaller footprint for narrower roof racks
- You prefer a steel basket with a waterproof bag
Skip if
- You require the maximum 54-inch length available
- You need a wider 39-inch platform
- You prefer a hard-shell carrier without a bag
Verdict: Garvee 51x36 Steel Roof Basket offers a secure 200 lb capacity with a waterproof bag, making it a practical choice for owners of narrower roof racks who prioritize cargo protection over maximum length.
Specifications side by side
| Spec | Garvee 54x39 Roof Rack Basket | Garvee 51x36 in Roof Basket |
|---|---|---|
| Mount Type | Roof-mount (crossbars) | roof-mount |
| Weight Capacity | 200 lbs | 200 lb |
| Basket Dimensions | 54" x 39" x 5" | 51 x 36 x 5 in |
| Material | Steel | steel |
| Side Rail Height | 5 inches | not stated |
| Load Capacity | 200 lb | 200 lb |
| Vehicle Type | SUV, Truck | SUV, Truck |
| Dimensions | 54 × 39 × 5 inches | 51 × 36 × 5 inches |
| Weight | 40 pounds | 40 pounds |
| Size | 54" x 39" | 51 x 36 |
| Color | Classic | black |
| Model | PAE_347 | PAU_0L2 |
Frequently asked questions
Does the 54x39 model fit all SUVs?
The 54x39 model is designed for SUVs and trucks with wide roof racks. Its 54-inch length and 39-inch width require ample space. If your vehicle has a narrow roof, this basket may overhang. Check your roof rack dimensions before purchasing to ensure a secure fit for your specific vehicle type.
How much weight can each basket hold?
Both the 54x39 and 51x36 Garvee baskets share an identical 200 lb load capacity. This limit applies to the steel frame structure itself. You must also consider your vehicle’s dynamic roof load limit, which is often lower. Distribute weight evenly across the basket to maintain stability and safety during travel.
Are both baskets made of steel?
Yes, both models are constructed from steel. The 54x39 is described as a steel roof rack basket. The 51x36 is explicitly called a steel roof basket. Steel provides durability and high load capacity. Both feature powder-coated finishes to resist rust and corrosion during outdoor use.
Do these baskets include a storage bag?
Both models include a 15 cubic foot roof bag. This bag provides additional waterproof storage for smaller items. It attaches to the basket frame, keeping gear secure. The bag helps protect contents from rain and dust. This feature is standard across both the larger and smaller Garvee basket options.
Which basket weighs more?
Neither basket weighs more than the other. Both the 54x39 and 51x36 models weigh exactly 40 pounds. This identical weight means they have similar impacts on your vehicle’s fuel efficiency and handling. The weight is distributed across the steel frame and included accessories.
Can I use the 51x36 on a truck?
Yes, the 51x36 model is suitable for trucks. The product data lists trucks as a compatible vehicle type. Its 51-inch length and 36-inch width offer a compact footprint. This size works well on trucks with narrower roof racks or crossbars, providing secure storage without excessive overhang.
What is the height of these baskets?
Both baskets have a height of 5 inches. This low profile helps maintain a low center of gravity. It also reduces wind resistance compared to taller carriers. The 5-inch height applies to the steel frame structure. This dimension is consistent across both the 54x39 and 51x36 models.