Malone SeaWing Saddle Style Universal or Malone VersaRail™ Bare Roof Cross? Which Malone Model to Buy
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Links on this page are affiliate links.
You are comparing the Malone SeaWing Saddle Style Universal vs VersaRail Bare Roof Cross. Both Malone products prioritize durability and weather resistance for outdoor gear transport. They share a compact design philosophy and corrosion-resistant materials. The main difference lies in their function and capacity. The SeaWing is a specialized kayak carrier with a 70 lb limit. The VersaRail is a universal cross rail system rated for 135 lbs. Your choice depends on whether you need dedicated kayak security or versatile roof space.
Key differences
| Aspect | Malone SeaWing Kayak Carrier | Malone VersaRail 50" Bare Roof Cross Rail System |
|---|---|---|
| Load Capacity | 70 lb | 135 lbs |
| Recommended Use | Kayak | Universal Cargo |
| Mount Type | Mid-Point on Existing Rails | Bare Roof |
| Length | 28 inches | 50 inches |
| Weight | 11.6 pounds | 10.5 pounds |
| Security Features | Bow and Stern Tie-Downs | Safety Attachment Straps |
Which one should you choose?
Choose Malone SeaWing Kayak Carrier if
- You already have roof cross rails and need a secure, low-profile mount specifically for a kayak.
- You want to minimize wind resistance and fuel consumption during highway transport.
- You need included bow and stern tie-downs to prevent kayak movement at speed.
Choose Malone VersaRail 50" Bare Roof Cross Rail System if
- Your car has bare roof rails or no roof racks at all.
- You need to carry heavy loads exceeding 70 pounds.
- You want a versatile rail that fits most standard rack accessories.
Verdict: Choose the SeaWing if you need a dedicated, stable solution for transporting a kayak on existing rails. Choose the VersaRail if you lack roof racks or need higher capacity for diverse cargo types. Both models offer robust construction and easy installation for their specific roles.
Malone Kayak Carrier vs Cross Rail
Intended Use
The Malone SeaWing Saddle Style Universal is designed specifically for transporting kayaks. It features V-style cradles that flex gently to support the hull securely. This dedicated shape reduces wind resistance and improves fuel efficiency during highway travel. In contrast, the Malone VersaRail Bare Roof Cross Rail System is a universal mounting solution. It provides a flat, rectangular bar that serves as a foundation for various accessories. While the SeaWing is a single-purpose kayak carrier, the VersaRail is a versatile rack component that can support boxes, bikes, or other gear when paired with appropriate adapters.
Load Capacity
Capacity differences are significant between these two Malone products. The SeaWing Saddle Style Universal supports up to 70 pounds. This limit is suitable for most recreational kayaks and ensures the rack remains stable under load. The VersaRail Bare Roof Cross Rail System offers a much higher load capacity of 135 pounds. This greater strength allows you to carry heavier cargo, such as large roof boxes or multiple pieces of equipment. If you plan to transport substantial weight, the VersaRail provides the necessary structural support, whereas the SeaWing is optimized for lighter, specialized kayak transport.
Mounting Compatibility
Installation methods differ based on your vehicle's existing roof structure. The SeaWing uses Malone’s Jawz universal mounting system. It fits round, square, and most factory oval cross rails without requiring tools or adapters. This makes it easy to attach to cars that already have crossbars. The VersaRail is designed for bare roofs. It uses vacuum tower bases with 75-pound pull strength and includes 1.5-inch wide safety attachment straps. It requires no additional tools, though a wrench is provided. You need a bare roof surface for the VersaRail, while the SeaWing needs existing crossbars.
Dimensions
Size and footprint matter for roof space management. The SeaWing measures 28 inches in length, 8 inches in width, and 6 inches in height. It weighs 11.6 pounds and takes up minimal roof space, leaving room for additional gear. The VersaRail is significantly longer at 50 inches, with a width of 8 inches and a height of 5.75 inches. It weighs slightly less at 10.5 pounds. The VersaRail spans across the roof, covering more area, while the compact SeaWing sits centrally on existing rails. Choose based on whether you need a long spanning bar or a compact, mid-point mount.
Security Features
Both products include features to keep your gear safe during transit. The SeaWing comes with heavy-duty bow and stern tie-down straps. These straps help prevent kayak movement at highway speeds, adding an extra layer of security beyond the cradle itself. The VersaRail does not include specific tie-down straps in its data, but its design includes 1.5-inch wide safety attachment straps for the vacuum towers themselves. These secure the rail to the roof. For securing the cargo itself, the SeaWing provides dedicated straps, while the VersaRail relies on the accessories you attach to its rectangular bar.
Which Malone Roof Rack Suits You
Kayak owners needing secure transport
The SeaWing Saddle Style Universal supports kayaks up to 70 pounds. Its V-style cradles flex to hold the hull securely. This design reduces wind resistance for better fuel efficiency. The unit measures 28 inches long and 11.6 pounds. It includes bow and stern tie-downs for highway safety. You get a stable, low-profile solution without needing extra tools.
Drivers needing versatile cargo space
The VersaRail system offers a 135-pound load capacity for general gear. At 50 inches long, it creates a flat platform for boxes or bags. The rectangular shape fits most rack accessories easily. Vacuum tower bases provide 75 pounds of pull strength. You get corrosion-resistant bars ready for installation. This option maximizes roof utility beyond just water sports.
Users wanting minimal roof footprint
The SeaWing Saddle Style is compact, measuring only 27.5 inches wide. It takes up minimal roof space compared to full cross bars. The mid-point mounting system allows for easy setup without tools. You retain room for additional gear alongside the kayak. The 70-pound capacity handles most recreational kayaks efficiently. This low-profile design keeps your vehicle aerodynamic and clear.
The products compared
Malone SeaWing Kayak Carrier
Best for: Universal mounting on existing cross rails
- Load Capacity
- 70 lb
- Vehicle Type
- Car
- Use
- Kayak
- Dimensions
- 28 × 8 × 6 inches
- Weight
- 11.6 pounds
View on Amazon: Malone SeaWing Kayak Carrier Affiliate link
The Malone SeaWing Saddle is a universal kayak rack for cars. It supports up to 70 pounds. The unit measures 28 inches long and weighs 11.6 pounds. It uses a no-tool Jawz mounting system for round, square, or oval rails. The V-style cradles flex to hold the hull securely. This design reduces wind resistance for better fuel efficiency. It includes bow and stern tie-down straps for safety.
Pros
- 70 lb load capacity
- No-tool Jawz universal mounting
- Fits round, square, and oval rails
- Includes bow and stern tie-downs
- Low-profile V-style cradles
Cons
- 11.6 lb weight adds roof load
- 70 lb limit restricts heavy gear
- Requires separate cross rails for installation
Good fit if
- You need a universal fit for existing cross bars
- You transport recreational kayaks under 70 lbs
- You want a low-profile design for fuel savings
Skip if
- You do not have cross rails installed
- You carry kayaks heavier than 70 lbs
- You need a permanent fixed rack system
Verdict: Malone SeaWing Saddle Kayak Carrier is a practical, universal option for owners of existing cross bars who need a secure, low-profile mount for standard kayaks.
Malone VersaRail 50" Bare Roof Cross Rail System
Best for: Bare roof vehicles needing 50-inch span
- Mount Type
- roof
- Load Capacity
- 135 lbs
- Dimensions
- 50 × 8 × 5.75 inches
- Weight
- 10.5 pounds
View on Amazon: Malone VersaRail 50" Bare Roof Cross Rail System Affiliate link
This Malone VersaRail system provides a 50-inch crossbar for bare roof vehicles. It features vacuum tower bases with 75 lb pull strength and 1.5-inch safety straps. The load capacity is 135 lbs. The rectangular load bar fits most accessories. The coating resists corrosion. It weighs 10.5 pounds and requires no additional tools for installation.
Pros
- 135 lb load capacity
- 75 lb pull strength vacuum towers
- Corrosion resistant load bar coating
- Rectangular shape fits most accessories
- No additional tools required
Cons
- 50-inch length may not fit wider vehicles
- Heavier at 10.5 pounds
- Limited to 75 lb tower pull strength
Good fit if
- You have a bare roof vehicle
- You need a 50-inch width
- You want a rectangular bar for accessories
Skip if
- You need a wider 58-inch option
- You prefer a saddle style carrier
- You need a lighter weight system
Verdict: Malone VersaRail 50" Bare Roof Cross Rail is a solid choice for bare roof vehicles needing a 50-inch span. It offers reliable vacuum mounting and a 135 lb capacity for your gear.
Specifications side by side
| Spec | Malone SeaWing Kayak Carrier | Malone VersaRail 50" Bare Roof Cross Rail System |
|---|---|---|
| Mount Type | not stated | roof |
| Load Capacity | 70 lb | 135 lbs |
| Vehicle Type | Car | not stated |
| Use | Kayak | not stated |
| Dimensions | 28 × 8 × 6 inches | 50 × 8 × 5.75 inches |
| Weight | 11.6 pounds | 10.5 pounds |
| Size | MPG107MD | 50" |
| Model | MPG107MD | MPG220 |
| Color | not stated | black |
Frequently asked questions
Can I use the SeaWing on a bare roof without crossbars?
No. The Malone SeaWing Saddle Style Universal is designed for existing cross rails. It mounts directly onto bars already installed on your vehicle. You cannot attach it to a bare roof surface. For bare roofs, you need a system that clamps or vacuums directly to the roof panel.
Does the VersaRail replace my crossbars or add to them?
The Malone VersaRail 50" Bare Roof Cross Rail replaces the need for separate crossbars. It is a complete system that mounts directly to your bare roof. It provides a 50-inch span for your cargo. You do not need additional bars when using this unit.
Which model is lighter to carry?
The Malone VersaRail 50" is slightly lighter. It weighs 10.5 pounds. The SeaWing Saddle Style Universal weighs 11.6 pounds. The difference is just over one pound. Both units are manageable for one person to lift and install.
What are the dimensions of the SeaWing carrier?
The SeaWing measures 28 inches in length. Its width is 8 inches. The height is 6 inches. It has a compact profile. These dimensions allow it to fit securely on most standard crossbar setups without excessive overhang.
How wide is the VersaRail crossbar system?
The Malone VersaRail 50" spans 50 inches. Its width is 8 inches. The height is 5.75 inches. This 50-inch span provides ample room for most cargo boxes or kayaks. It is designed to bridge the gap between roof rails on bare roofs.
Is the VersaRail suitable for carrying a kayak?
Yes. The VersaRail offers a 135 lb capacity. This is sufficient for most kayaks. However, it is a general crossbar system. It does not have dedicated V-cradles like the SeaWing. You may need additional straps or pads to secure the kayak hull safely.
What vehicle type do these products support?
Both products are intended for car use. The SeaWing requires a car with existing crossbars. The VersaRail requires a car with a bare roof. Both are designed for standard passenger vehicles. They are not intended for trucks or SUVs with unique roof structures.