Mockins 500 lb Hitch Cargo or Mockins 84"x39"x5" XL Extendable Roof? Which Mockins Model to Buy
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Links on this page are affiliate links.
When comparing mockins 500 lb hitch cargo vs 84 x39 x5 xl extendable roof carriers, you face a choice between ground-level utility and overhead space. Both units are steel baskets that include weather-resistant bags and mounting hardware. The main difference lies in their installation method and weight limits. One mounts to a trailer hitch receiver for heavy loads, while the other secures to roof crossbars for larger volume storage. You must decide which mounting style fits your vehicle and cargo needs.
Key differences
| Aspect | Mockins 500 lb Hitch Cargo Carrier with Bag | Mockins 84"x39"x5" XL Extendable Roof Basket |
|---|---|---|
| Mount Type | Hitch-mount (2-inch receiver) | Roof-mount (crossbars) |
| Weight Capacity | 500 lb | 250 lb |
| Basket Dimensions | 60 x 20 x 6 in | 84 x 39 x 5 in |
| Bag Volume | 20 Cu Ft | 35 Cu Ft |
| Key Feature | Folding design with tilt | Extendable length (40-84 in) |
Which one should you choose?
Choose Mockins 500 lb Hitch Cargo Carrier with Bag if
- You need to carry heavy items like coolers or tools up to 500 lb.
- You want to keep your vehicle's roof clear for aerodynamics and height clearance.
- You prefer a basket that folds flat for easy garage storage.
Choose Mockins 84"x39"x5" XL Extendable Roof Basket if
- You require extra-long storage for bulky gear like kayaks or furniture.
- You have roof crossbars already installed and want to use them.
- You need a larger 35 Cu Ft bag for seasonal or travel items.
Verdict: The hitch carrier is the better choice if you prioritize maximum weight capacity and ground-level loading. The roof basket is superior if you need extended length and greater total volume for oversized items. Select the model that matches your vehicle's mounting points and your heaviest cargo.
Hitch vs Roof Carrier Specs
Load Capacity
The Mockins 500 lb Hitch Cargo Carrier supports up to 500 pounds of gear. This high limit allows you to haul heavy coolers, tools, or bulk items without worrying about weight restrictions. The Mockins 84"x39"x5" XL Extendable Roof Carrier supports 250 pounds. While sufficient for luggage and camping gear, it holds half the weight of the hitch model. If you frequently move heavy equipment or large quantities of supplies, the hitch carrier provides double the capacity. The roof basket is better suited for lighter, bulky loads where weight is not the primary constraint.
Basket Dimensions
The hitch carrier measures 60 inches long by 20 inches wide. This narrower profile fits well behind sedans and smaller SUVs without obstructing the rear view. The roof carrier extends to 84 inches long and 39 inches wide. This larger footprint offers significantly more surface area for spreading out gear. The extendable design allows you to shorten it to 40 or 63 inches if needed. For carrying wide items like kayaks or long lumber, the roof basket provides a much broader platform than the hitch carrier’s compact base.
Mount Type
The hitch carrier mounts directly into a 2-inch receiver hitch on your vehicle. This installation is straightforward and does not require climbing onto the roof. It sits low, keeping your center of gravity stable. The roof carrier requires existing crossbars on your vehicle’s roof. You must secure it using the included buckle and ratchet straps. This method demands more effort to install and remove. If your vehicle lacks roof rails or crossbars, the hitch carrier is the only viable option. The hitch mount also keeps the carrier accessible from the ground.
Included Bag Size
The hitch carrier bundle includes a 20 cubic foot weatherproof bag. This size is adequate for standard luggage or a weekend’s worth of camping gear. The roof carrier bundle includes a larger 35 cubic foot bag. This extra volume allows you to store bulkier items like sleeping bags, tents, or seasonal clothing. The roof bag is made from abrasion-resistant 840D vinyl with reinforced seams. If you need maximum storage volume for long trips, the roof carrier’s included bag offers nearly double the capacity of the hitch carrier’s bag.
Security Features
The hitch carrier includes a dedicated license plate bracket and high-visibility reflectors to meet DOT compliance. It also comes with a locking hitch pin to secure the carrier to the receiver. The roof carrier includes a combination lock for the cargo bag and a cargo net with ABS hooks. The hitch carrier’s lock protects the entire unit from being stolen from the receiver. The roof carrier’s lock protects the contents of the bag. Both models offer security, but the hitch carrier’s integrated locking pin provides a more robust anti-theft solution for the hardware itself.
Which Mockins Carrier Suits Your Needs
Heavy haulers needing ground access
You need to move heavy loads without climbing. The 500 lb hitch carrier supports substantial weight. Its 60-inch length fits standard gear. The 2-inch shank rise helps avoid scraping on driveways. You get a secure, ground-level solution that keeps your interior cabin clear of bulky items.
Travelers maximizing roof space
You require maximum storage volume on your vehicle roof. This extendable basket reaches 84 inches long. It supports 250 lbs of cargo. The 39-inch width accommodates wide items. You benefit from a 35 cubic ft weatherproof bag and a wind deflector to reduce noise and drag while driving.
Drivers with tight parking spots
You park in low-clearance garages or tight spots. The hitch carrier tilts upright, reducing its profile. Its 60-inch length is shorter than the roof option. You avoid height restrictions entirely by keeping cargo at ground level. The folding design makes storage and daily parking significantly easier for your specific vehicle setup.
The products compared
Mockins 500 lb Hitch Cargo Carrier with Bag
Best for: Hauling heavy, bulky gear with a 2-inch hitch
- Mount Type
- Hitch-mount
- Weight Capacity
- 500 lbs
- Basket Dimensions
- 60" x 20" x 6"
- Material
- Steel
- Receiver Size
- 2"
- Load Capacity
- 500 lb
View on Amazon: Mockins 500 lb Hitch Cargo Carrier with Bag Affiliate link
This hitch-mounted carrier offers 500 lb capacity in a 60 x 20 x 6 inch steel basket. It includes a 20 cubic foot waterproof bag and a 10-year warranty. The design features a 2-inch shank rise for better ground clearance and a folding mechanism for compact storage. You get high side rails and a bungee net to keep loads secure. It is ideal for hauling heavy gear like coolers or camping equipment without using interior space.
Pros
- 500 lb weight capacity for heavy loads
- Includes 20 cu ft waterproof bag with heat-sealed seams
- 2-inch shank rise reduces scraping on driveways
- Folding design allows upright storage for tight garages
- 10-year limited warranty on powder-coated steel
Cons
- Basket is only 20 inches wide, limiting width for wide items
- Fixed 6-inch side rails may restrict tall cargo
- Requires a 2-inch receiver, not compatible with 1.25-inch hitches
Good fit if
- You need to haul heavy gear like coolers or tools
- You want to keep your vehicle interior free of cargo
- You have a 2-inch receiver hitch on your vehicle
Skip if
- You need to carry wide items that exceed 20 inches
- Your vehicle only has a 1.25-inch receiver hitch
- You prefer a roof-mounted solution to keep the rear open
Verdict: Mockins 500 lb Steel Hitch Cargo Carrier is a heavy-duty solution for users who need to transport bulky, weighty items without sacrificing interior space. Its 500 lb capacity and included waterproof bag make it suitable for camping or work trips.
Mockins 84"x39"x5" XL Extendable Roof Basket
Best for: adjustable roof storage with included accessories
- Mount Type
- Roof-mount
- Weight Capacity
- 250 lbs
- Basket Dimensions
- 84"x39"x5"
- Material
- Steel
- Vehicle Type
- Car, SUV, Truck
- Includes Bag
- With Bag
View on Amazon: Mockins 84"x39"x5" XL Extendable Roof Basket Affiliate link
This Mockins roof carrier is an extendable steel basket measuring 84 by 39 by 5 inches. It weighs 54 pounds and supports up to 250 pounds. The set includes a 35 cubic foot waterproof bag, straps, and a cargo net. It mounts to crossbars on cars or SUVs. The adjustable length helps you fit various loads. It suits drivers who need flexible roof storage for gear.
Pros
- Extendable design adjusts to 40, 63, or 84 inches
- Includes a 35 cubic foot waterproof cargo bag
- Supports up to 250 pounds of gear
- Built from rust-resistant steel with a protective coating
Cons
- Heavier at 54 pounds compared to lighter carriers
- Lower 250-pound capacity than hitch carriers
- Requires vehicle crossbars for installation
Good fit if
- You need adjustable length for different cargo sizes
- You want a complete kit with straps and a bag
- You drive an SUV or car with crossbars
Skip if
- You prefer a hitch-mounted carrier
- You need a capacity over 250 pounds
- You want a lighter unit under 40 pounds
Verdict: Mockins 84x39x5 XL Extendable Roof Carrier offers a versatile, all-in-one solution for drivers with crossbars. It is best for those who prioritize adjustable length and included accessories over maximum weight capacity.
Specifications side by side
| Spec | Mockins 500 lb Hitch Cargo Carrier with Bag | Mockins 84"x39"x5" XL Extendable Roof Basket |
|---|---|---|
| Mount Type | Hitch-mount | Roof-mount |
| Weight Capacity | 500 lbs | 250 lbs |
| Basket Dimensions | 60" x 20" x 6" | 84"x39"x5" |
| Material | Steel | Steel |
| Receiver Size | 2" | not stated |
| Load Capacity | 500 lb | not stated |
| Vehicle Type | Car, SUV, Truck | Car, SUV, Truck |
| Includes Bag | With Bag | With Bag |
| Dimensions | 60 × 20 × 6 inches | 84 × 39 × 6 inches |
| Weight | 55 pounds | 54 pounds |
| Size | 60"x20"x6" + 20 Cu Ft Bag | 84"x39"x5" - 35 Cu.Ft. Bag |
| Color | Black/Orange | Black/Blue |
| Model | MACCBS30 | MA-RC-84X39-35BLU-92 |
Frequently asked questions
Can I install the 84 inch roof basket on any car?
The Mockins 84x39x5 XL Extendable Roof Basket is designed for cars. It requires existing roof crossbars for secure attachment. You must ensure your vehicle has compatible crossbars before purchasing. This unit mounts directly to those bars rather than clamping to the roof rails.
Does the hitch carrier include a storage bag?
Yes, the Mockins 500 lb Hitch Cargo Carrier comes with a waterproof bag. The bag measures 20 cubic feet. It helps protect your gear from rain and dust while you are driving. The bag is included with the steel carrier frame.
How much does the steel hitch carrier weigh?
The Mockins 500 lb Hitch Cargo Carrier weighs 52 pounds. This weight is for the steel basket itself. It does not include the weight of the included storage bag. You should account for this base weight when loading your vehicle.
Is the roof basket adjustable in length?
Yes, the Mockins 84x39x5 XL Extendable Roof Basket is extendable. It features a telescoping design that allows you to adjust the length. This helps you fit various sizes of gear. The maximum length is 84 inches when fully extended.
What receiver size does the hitch carrier need?
The Mockins 500 lb Hitch Cargo Carrier requires a 2-inch hitch receiver. It will not fit into smaller 1.25-inch receivers. Ensure your vehicle has a standard 2-inch square opening before attempting installation. The steel shank is designed specifically for this size.
What is the total capacity of the roof basket?
The Mockins 84x39x5 XL Extendable Roof Basket has a 35 cubic foot capacity. This volume includes space for the included storage bag. It offers ample room for luggage, camping gear, or sports equipment. The dimensions are 84 inches long by 39 inches wide.
Does the roof basket come with mounting hardware?
Yes, the Mockins 84x39x5 XL Extendable Roof Basket includes mounting hardware. You need to attach the unit to your vehicle's crossbars. The package contains the necessary straps or clamps for secure installation. Always tighten all connections before driving to ensure safety.