Mockins 60"x24"x6" XL Heavy Duty or Mockins 84"x39"x5" XL Extendable Waterproof? Which Mockins Model to Buy
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Links on this page are affiliate links.
Choosing between the mockins 60 x24 x6 xl heavy duty vs 84 x39 x5 xl extendable waterproof requires understanding their distinct designs. Both carriers offer robust metal construction and include essential securing accessories like straps and nets. They also share a 10-year warranty for long-term reliability. The primary difference lies in their mounting location and capacity. One is a hitch-mounted basket with higher weight limits, while the other is a roof-mounted system with extendable length. You need to decide which vehicle attachment fits your hauling needs.
Key differences
| Aspect | Mockins 60x24x6 XL Heavy Duty Hitch Carrier | Mockins 84"x39"x5" XL Extendable Roof Basket |
|---|---|---|
| Mount Type | Hitch-mount (2-inch receiver) | Roof-mount (crossbars) |
| Load Capacity | 500 lb | 250 lb |
| Basket Dimensions | 60 x 24 x 6 in | 84 x 39 x 5 in |
| Extendability | Not listed | Adjustable to 40", 63", or 84" |
| Included Bag | Not listed | 35 cubic ft waterproof soft bag |
Which one should you choose?
Choose Mockins 60x24x6 XL Heavy Duty Hitch Carrier if
- You need to carry heavy equipment up to 500 lbs
- You prefer a fixed-size basket that mounts to your trailer hitch
- You want a system without a bulky soft bag on your roof
Choose Mockins 84"x39"x5" XL Extendable Roof Basket if
- You require a longer cargo area that adjusts to 84 inches
- You want to keep your gear dry with a waterproof roof bag
- You are hauling bulky items that fit better on a wider roof rack
Verdict: The hitch carrier is the better choice for heavy loads and structural strength, supporting up to 500 lbs. The roof carrier suits those needing adjustable length and weather protection for softer goods. Select the model that matches your vehicle's mounting points and specific weight requirements.
Mockins Hitch vs Roof Carrier Specs
Mounting style
Product A uses a hitch-mount design that plugs directly into a 2-inch receiver. This setup keeps the cargo low to the ground, which can improve stability and aerodynamics for some drivers. Product B mounts to roof crossbars, placing the load high above your vehicle. Roof mounting is ideal for SUVs, RVs, and cars with hitch restrictions. You must choose based on your vehicle’s available attachment points. If you have a receiver, Product A is straightforward. If you rely on roof rails, Product B is the only option. Each method serves different vehicle configurations.
Load capacity
Product A boasts a 500-pound weight capacity, making it suitable for heavy items like construction materials, large toolboxes, or multiple pieces of heavy equipment. Product B supports up to 250 pounds. While sufficient for luggage and camping gear, it cannot handle the same extreme loads as the hitch carrier. The higher capacity of Product A provides greater flexibility for industrial or heavy-duty use. For standard family trips with moderate gear, both are adequate, but Product A offers significantly more margin for error when hauling dense materials.
Basket dimensions
Product A measures 60 inches long by 24 inches wide. Its narrow width makes it easier to fit in tight garage spaces or between obstacles. Product B is much larger at 84 inches long and 39 inches wide. This expansive surface area allows you to carry bulky items like kayaks, long lumber, or multiple large suitcases simultaneously. The extendable design of Product B adds versatility, allowing you to shorten it to 40 inches if needed. Product A offers a compact footprint, while Product B provides maximum surface area.
Water protection
Product B includes a 35 cubic foot waterproof soft cargo bag made from 840D vinyl with reinforced seams and waterproof zippers. This bag shields your gear from rain and snow, keeping contents dry. Product A is an open metal basket. It does not include a waterproof bag, meaning your cargo is exposed to the elements unless you use your own covers. If you frequently drive in wet weather or need to protect sensitive items like electronics or clothing, Product B’s integrated waterproof bag is a significant practical advantage.
Weight and portability
Product A weighs 50 pounds, while Product B weighs 38 pounds. Product B is lighter, which makes it easier to lift onto your roof and remove for storage. However, Product B includes a large cargo bag and multiple straps, adding to the total package weight. Product A is a standalone metal unit. If you prioritize a lighter individual component for easier handling, Product B has the edge. If you prefer a rigid, standalone structure without the bulk of a soft bag, Product A is more manageable in terms of loose parts.
Which Mockins Carrier Fits Your Needs
You need to haul heavy loads low to the ground
The hitch-mounted model supports up to 500 pounds, far exceeding the roof basket's 250-pound limit. Its 60-inch length keeps cargo low, improving stability. You get a 51-pound metal build that resists rust. This setup is ideal for transporting heavy equipment or large items without stressing your vehicle's roof structure.
You require maximum volume for bulky soft goods
This roof carrier offers a 35 cubic foot waterproof bag, providing significantly more storage space than the hitch basket. The extendable frame adjusts from 40 to 84 inches to fit various loads. The 840D vinyl bag shields gear from rain. You also benefit from a wind deflector that reduces drag and noise while driving.
You want to keep gear dry and secure
The included waterproof bag features reinforced seams and water-resistant zippers under a protective flap. Rubber-covered screws help prevent leaks into the frame. A combination lock adds anti-theft protection for your valuables. The aerodynamic design helps maintain fuel efficiency while keeping your cargo dry and safe from the elements during travel.
The products compared
Mockins 60x24x6 XL Heavy Duty Hitch Carrier
Best for: Heavy loads up to 500 lbs
- Mount Type
- Hitch-mount
- Weight Capacity
- 500 lbs
- Basket Dimensions
- 60"x24"x6"
- Material
- Steel
- Side Rail Height
- 6 inches
- Receiver Size
- 2"
View on Amazon: Mockins 60x24x6 XL Heavy Duty Hitch Carrier Affiliate link
This is a hitch-mount cargo carrier with a 60 by 24 by 6 inch basket. It supports a 500-pound load and weighs 51 pounds. The metal build resists rust and corrosion. It fits standard 2-inch receivers and includes straps and a cargo net. You should use this if you need high capacity for heavy gear like construction materials or large luggage.
Pros
- 500-pound weight capacity
- 60x24x6 inch basket size
- Includes stabilizer and lock set
- Comes with 10-foot ratchet straps
- Includes expandable 6mm cargo net
Cons
- Narrow 24-inch width limits wide loads
- Low 6-inch height restricts tall items
- Heavy 51-pound metal construction
Good fit if
- You need to haul heavy loads up to 500 pounds
- You have a 2-inch receiver hitch
- You want a rust-resistant metal basket
Skip if
- You need to carry wide items over 24 inches
- You require a roof-mounted carrier
- You want a lightweight aluminum option
Verdict: Mockins 60x24x6 Heavy Duty Hitch Carrier offers high capacity for heavy loads but restricts wide or tall items due to its narrow, low profile. It fits buyers with 2-inch hitches who prioritize weight limits over cargo dimensions.
Mockins 84"x39"x5" XL Extendable Roof Basket
Best for: Large, irregular cargo on SUVs
- Mount Type
- Roof-mount
- Weight Capacity
- 250 lbs
- Basket Dimensions
- 84"x39"x5"
- Material
- Steel
- Vehicle Type
- Car, SUV, Truck
- Includes Bag
- With Bag
View on Amazon: Mockins 84"x39"x5" XL Extendable Roof Basket Affiliate link
This Mockins roof basket measures 84 by 39 by 5 inches and weighs 54 pounds. It supports up to 250 pounds and mounts to crossbars. The steel frame extends to 40, 63, or 84 inches. You get a 35 cubic foot waterproof bag, straps, and a lock. It suits large vehicles needing flexible cargo space.
Pros
- Extendable design offers 40, 63, and 84-inch lengths
- 250-pound weight capacity for heavy loads
- Includes 35 cubic foot waterproof vinyl bag
- Comes with straps, cargo net, and combination lock
Cons
- 54-pound total weight is heavy for solo handling
- 35 cubic foot bag limits soft cargo volume
- No mention of integrated tie-down points on frame
Good fit if
- You need adjustable length for varying cargo sizes
- You require a high 250-pound weight capacity
- You want a complete kit with straps and lock
Skip if
- You have narrow roof racks under 39 inches wide
- You prefer a lightweight carrier under 40 pounds
- You need a rigid hard-shell cargo box
Verdict: Mockins 84x39x5 Extendable Roof Carrier fits those who need a heavy-duty, adjustable steel basket with a waterproof bag. It is ideal for hauling large or irregular items on SUVs and trucks with crossbars.
Specifications side by side
| Spec | Mockins 60x24x6 XL Heavy Duty Hitch Carrier | Mockins 84"x39"x5" XL Extendable Roof Basket |
|---|---|---|
| Mount Type | Hitch-mount | Roof-mount |
| Weight Capacity | 500 lbs | 250 lbs |
| Basket Dimensions | 60"x24"x6" | 84"x39"x5" |
| Material | Steel | Steel |
| Side Rail Height | 6 inches | not stated |
| Receiver Size | 2" | not stated |
| Load Capacity | 500 lb | not stated |
| Vehicle Type | Car, SUV, Truck | Car, SUV, Truck |
| Includes Bag | not stated | With Bag |
| Dimensions | 60 × 24 × 6 inches | 84 × 39 × 6 inches |
| Weight | 50 pounds | 54 pounds |
| Size | Large: 60"x24"x6" | 84"x39"x5" - 35 Cu.Ft. Bag |
| Color | Black | Black/Blue |
| Model | MA-HC-60X24-87 | MA-RC-84X39-35BLU-92 |
Frequently asked questions
Which Mockins carrier holds more weight?
The Mockins 60x24x6 hitch carrier supports up to 500 pounds. This heavy-duty limit is ideal for transporting dense items like tools or equipment. The roof basket model has a lower capacity, making it less suitable for extremely heavy loads.
Can I carry wide items on the hitch carrier?
No, the hitch carrier is only 24 inches wide. This narrow profile restricts wide items such as kayaks or large pallets. If you need to haul wider cargo, the 39-inch wide roof basket provides the necessary space.
Which model is better for irregular shaped cargo?
The 84x39x5 roof basket is better for irregular shapes. Its open basket design allows you to stack uneven items like lumber or furniture. The hitch carrier has a low 6-inch height, which limits the vertical space for bulky objects.
How much does each carrier weigh?
The hitch carrier weighs 50 pounds. The roof basket weighs 54 pounds. Both are substantial metal structures. You will need to lift the roof basket onto your vehicle's crossbars, while the hitch carrier slides into your receiver.
Does the roof basket come with a bag?
Yes, the roof basket includes a 35 cubic foot waterproof bag. This bag protects your cargo from rain and dust. The hitch carrier does not include a bag, so you must secure items with straps or nets.
Which carrier is longer?
The roof basket is longer at 84 inches. The hitch carrier is 60 inches long. The extra length on the roof model allows you to carry longer items like pipes or ladders, provided your vehicle has adequate crossbar spacing.
What vehicle types work with the roof basket?
The roof basket is designed for cars, SUVs, and trucks with crossbars. It mounts securely to existing roof racks. The hitch carrier requires a 2-inch receiver hitch, which is common on trucks and some SUVs but rare on standard cars.
Which model offers better stability for heavy loads?
The hitch carrier offers better stability for heavy loads. It sits low to the ground, lowering your vehicle's center of gravity. The roof basket raises cargo high up, which can affect handling when carrying heavy or bulky items.