Looking Beyond the Mockins 84"x39"x5" XL Extendable Waterproof? 6 Alternatives Worth a Look

How alternatives compare to Mockins

KAIRAY 60"x24"x14.4" Hitch Cargo Carrier

The KAIRAY hitch carrier moves your cargo away from the roofline, which can improve aerodynamics and reduce wind noise compared to the Mockins basket. It offers a higher 500 lb load capacity, doubling the Mockins limit. However, it requires a 2-inch hitch receiver, whereas the Mockins mounts to crossbars. The KAIRAY is 60 inches long and 24 inches wide, making it narrower than the Mockins 39-inch frame. You gain 500 lbs of capacity but lose the ability to use it on vehicles without a hitch. This option suits those prioritizing heavy hauling over roof-mounted versatility.

Mockins 60"x20"x6" 500 lb Hitch Cargo Carrier

This Mockins hitch model also delivers a 500 lb capacity, significantly exceeding the roof basket's 250 lb limit. It mounts to a hitch receiver rather than crossbars, offering a lower center of gravity. The basket is 60 inches long and 20 inches wide, which is narrower than the 84-inch extendable roof basket. A key difference is the integrated safety lights, which the roof basket lacks. You gain heavy-duty hauling capability and visibility features but sacrifice the extendable length and roof-mounted convenience. This choice fits users who need maximum weight support and do not have roof crossbars.

Mockins 64x39x6 Extendable Roof Basket

The Mockins 64-inch extendable basket shares the same 250 lb capacity and steel material as the 84-inch model. It is shorter, measuring 64 inches compared to 84 inches, and weighs 51 pounds versus 54 pounds. It includes a waterproof bag and a cargo net, similar to the larger version. The side rail height is 6 inches, slightly taller than the 5-inch rails on the XL model. You get a more compact frame that is easier to store when not in use. This alternative is ideal if you need less length but still want the extendable feature and bundled accessories on your roof.

Mockins 6" Raised Hitch Cargo Carrier 500 lb

This Mockins hitch carrier provides a 500 lb capacity, which is double the roof basket's limit. It is 60 inches long and 20 inches wide, making it narrower than the 84-inch roof basket. The unit weighs 60 pounds and includes a waterproof bag. Unlike the roof basket, it mounts to a hitch receiver, keeping cargo off the roof. You gain substantial weight capacity and stability but lose the ability to use it on vehicles without a hitch. This option is best for heavy hauling needs where roof space is insufficient or unavailable for large loads.

JOYTUTUS Aluminum Roof Cargo Basket 64x40

The JOYTUTUS aluminum basket weighs only 32 pounds, which is significantly lighter than the 54-pound Mockins steel basket. It offers a 150 lb capacity, which is lower than the Mockins 250 lb limit. The frame is 64 inches long and 40 inches wide, providing a similar footprint but with less weight. Aluminum construction resists rust without needing a protective coating like the steel Mockins. You gain ease of installation and reduced roof load but sacrifice 100 lbs of capacity. This choice suits drivers with lighter loads who prioritize weight savings over maximum hauling strength.

WEIZE 54" x 34" Roof Rack Basket

The WEIZE steel basket has a 200 lb capacity, which is lower than the Mockins 250 lb limit. It measures 54 inches long and 34 inches wide, making it smaller than the 84-inch Mockins frame. The basket includes a waterproof bag and cargo net, similar to the Mockins bundle. It is designed for narrower crossbars, offering flexibility in mounting. You gain a more compact solution for moderate loads but lose the extendable length and higher weight capacity. This alternative fits users with smaller vehicles or crossbars who do not need to transport long gear.

Quick picks

Our 7 picks

1 Best overall

Mockins 84"x39"x5" XL Extendable Roof Basket

Best for: transporting long gear on crossbars

Mount Type

Roof-mount

Weight Capacity

250 lbs

Basket Dimensions

84"x39"x5"

Material

Steel

Vehicle Type

Car, SUV, Truck

Includes Bag

With Bag

View on Amazon: Mockins 84"x39"x5" XL Extendable Roof Basket Affiliate link

This Mockins roof basket extends to 84 inches and supports 250 pounds. It mounts to crossbars and includes a 35 cubic foot waterproof bag. The steel frame weighs 54 pounds total. You get ratchet straps, a cargo net, and a lock. It suits travelers needing extra length for large items on SUVs or trucks.

Pros

• Extends to 84 inches for long gear
• Includes 35 cubic foot waterproof bag
• 250 pound weight capacity
• Rust-resistant steel construction
• Includes lock and cargo net

Cons

• 54 pound total weight is heavy
• 250 pound limit is lower than some hitches
• Requires existing crossbars for mounting

Good fit if

• You need to carry long items like kayaks
• You want a complete bundle with straps
• Your vehicle has crossbars

Skip if

• You prefer a lighter aluminum basket
• You need more than 250 pounds capacity
• Your vehicle lacks crossbars

Verdict: Mockins 84" Extendable Steel Roof Basket offers significant length for large loads. It is a solid choice for those who need to transport long gear and want a bundled solution.

2 Best travel

KAIRAY 60"x24"x14.4" Hitch Cargo Carrier

Best for: heavy luggage and camping gear transport

Mount Type

hitch-mount

Weight Capacity

500 lb

Basket Dimensions

60" x 24" x 14.4"

Material

steel

Side Rail Height

14.4"

Receiver Size

2"

View on Amazon: KAIRAY 60"x24"x14.4" Hitch Cargo Carrier Affiliate link

This hitch-mounted steel basket offers 500 lbs capacity and 14.4-inch side rails. It includes a waterproof bag and net for secure transport. The 60x24-inch platform fits 2-inch receivers. You get rust-resistant construction with reflectors for visibility. It suits travelers needing extra luggage space without roof rack installation.

Pros

• 500 lb distributed weight capacity
• 14.4-inch raised side rails prevent sliding
• Includes waterproof cargo bag and net
• Steel construction with rust-resistant coating
• Built-in safety reflectors for night driving

Cons

• Hitch mount requires a 2-inch receiver
• Basket alone weighs 68 pounds
• Narrow 24-inch width limits load width

Good fit if

• You need to carry bulky luggage or camping gear
• Your vehicle has a 2-inch hitch receiver
• You want a high-capacity carrier with included storage

Skip if

• Your vehicle lacks a hitch receiver
• You need to mount cargo on the roof
• You require a wider platform for oversized items

Verdict: KAIRAY 60x24x14.4" Hitch Cargo Carrier provides robust steel capacity for heavy loads. It fits drivers who prioritize weight limits and included storage bags over roof-mounted convenience.

3 Also great

Mockins 60"x20"x6" 500 lb Hitch Cargo Carrier

Best for: Heavy hauling with integrated safety lights

Mount Type

Hitch-mount

Weight Capacity

500 lbs.

Basket Dimensions

60" x 20" x 6"

Material

Steel

Receiver Size

2-inch

Load Capacity

500 lb

View on Amazon: Mockins 60"x20"x6" 500 lb Hitch Cargo Carrier Affiliate link

This hitch-mount rack offers 500 lb capacity and a 60x20x6 inch steel platform. It includes a 20 cu ft waterproof bag, rear lights, and a license plate bracket. The 56 lb steel frame fits 2-inch receivers. It suits those needing heavy hauling with integrated lighting and weather protection for gear.

Pros

• 500 lb weight capacity
• Includes waterproof cargo bag
• Integrated rear lights and license plate bracket
• Steel construction with rust-resistant finish

Cons

• Narrow 20-inch width limits wide items
• Heavy 56 lb steel frame
• Bag volume limited to 20 cubic feet

Good fit if

• You need to haul heavy loads up to 500 lbs
• You want integrated rear lights for safety
• You prefer a steel frame for durability

Skip if

• You require a wide platform for bulky items
• You want a lightweight aluminum carrier
• You do not have a 2-inch hitch receiver

Verdict: Mockins 60x20x6 Hitch Cargo Carrier is a robust, heavy-duty option for users prioritizing load capacity and integrated lighting over width or portability.

4 Also great

Mockins 64x39x6 Extendable Roof Basket

Best for: Expandable roof storage with bag

Mount Type

roof-mount

Weight Capacity

250 lb

Basket Dimensions

64x39x6 in

Material

steel

Vehicle Type

Car

Includes Bag

With Bag

View on Amazon: Mockins 64x39x6 Extendable Roof Basket Affiliate link

This Mockins bundle includes a steel roof rack basket and a waterproof cargo bag. The basket measures 64 by 39 by 6 inches and extends from 43 to 64 inches. It supports 250 pounds of gear. The included 16 cubic foot bag adds extra storage. This setup suits drivers who need expandable roof space for SUVs or cars.

Pros

• 250-pound weight capacity
• Extendable basket length from 43 to 64 inches
• Includes 16 cubic foot waterproof bag
• Anti-rust steel construction

Cons

• Heavier 51-pound build
• Lower 250-pound limit compared to 500-pound rivals
• Steel frame requires crossbars for installation

Good fit if

• You need expandable cargo space
• You want a waterproof bag included
• You drive an SUV or car

Skip if

• You require a 500-pound capacity
• You prefer lightweight aluminum racks
• You need a hitch-mounted carrier

Verdict: Mockins Steel Roof Basket & Bag offers a practical steel frame with extendable length and a waterproof bag. It fits drivers who need 250 pounds of capacity and extra soft storage on their roof.

5 Also great

Mockins 6" Raised Hitch Cargo Carrier 500 lb

Best for: heavy duty hauling and all-weather protection

Mount Type

Hitch-mount

Weight Capacity

500 lbs

Basket Dimensions

60" x 20" x 6"

Material

Steel

Side Rail Height

6"

Load Capacity

500 lb

View on Amazon: Mockins 6" Raised Hitch Cargo Carrier 500 lb Affiliate link

This hitch-mount cargo carrier is built from steel and supports up to 500 lb. The basket measures 60 x 20 x 6 inches and sits 6 inches above the receiver. It includes a waterproof bag and securing straps. You get a rigid platform for heavy items like firewood or construction supplies. The 5-year warranty covers long-term use. This bundle suits those needing high capacity and all-weather protection for rear-mounted loads.

Pros

• 500 lb weight capacity for heavy loads
• 6-inch raised rails keep gear contained
• Includes waterproof bag with abrasion-resistant vinyl
• Comes with stabilizer, lock, and securing straps

Cons

• Narrow 20-inch width limits wide items
• 60-inch length is shorter than roof boxes
• Steel construction adds significant weight to vehicle

Good fit if

• You need to haul heavy materials like firewood
• You want a secure, all-weather cargo solution
• You prefer a hitch-mounted carrier over roof racks

Skip if

• You need to carry wide or oversized items
• You want to keep your rear license plate visible
• You prefer a lightweight aluminum carrier for easy handling

Verdict: Mockins 60x20x6 Steel Hitch Carrier provides a robust 500 lb platform for heavy, weather-sensitive gear. You should buy this if you prioritize load strength and included accessories over maximum volume or rear visibility.

6 Best premium

JOYTUTUS Aluminum Roof Cargo Basket 64x40

Best for: lightweight aluminum roof storage with moderate capacity

Mount Type

roof-mount (crossbars)

Weight Capacity

150 lbs

Basket Dimensions

64" x 40" x 8"

Material

aluminum alloy

Side Rail Height

8"

Load Capacity

150 lb

View on Amazon: JOYTUTUS Aluminum Roof Cargo Basket 64x40 Affiliate link

This JOYTUTUS basket measures 64 by 40 inches with an 8-inch side rail height. It is made from aluminum alloy and weighs 32 pounds. The design supports up to 150 pounds of gear. You need crossbars for installation. The aerodynamic shape helps reduce wind noise. It suits travelers who want to free up interior space in their car, SUV, or truck.

Pros

• Aluminum alloy construction resists rust and corrosion.
• Lightweight design weighs only 32 pounds.
• Holds up to 150 pounds of cargo.
• Aerodynamic shape reduces wind resistance.
• Fits aerodynamic, oval, square, and round crossbars.

Cons

• 150-pound capacity is lower than many competitors.
• Requires separate crossbars for mounting.
• No mention of a locking mechanism for security.

Good fit if

• You need a lightweight carrier that reduces vehicle load.
• You already have crossbars installed on your vehicle.
• You want a rust-resistant basket for all-weather use.

Skip if

• You plan to carry loads over 150 pounds.
• Your vehicle does not have crossbars.
• You require a hitch-mounted carrier instead of a roof option.

Verdict: JOYTUTUS Aluminum Roof Cargo Basket 64x40 offers a sturdy, lightweight aluminum frame for moderate loads. It is best for drivers with existing crossbars who prioritize weight savings over maximum capacity.

7 Best budget

WEIZE 54" x 34" Roof Rack Basket

Best for: narrow crossbars and moderate loads

Mount Type

roof-mount

Weight Capacity

200 lbs

Basket Dimensions

54x34x6 inches

Material

tubular steel

Side Rail Height

6 inches

Load Capacity

200 lb

View on Amazon: WEIZE 54" x 34" Roof Rack Basket Affiliate link

This WEIZE roof rack basket measures 54 by 34 by 6 inches. It supports a 200-pound load capacity. The tubular steel frame adjusts from 35 to 54 inches wide. It fits crossbars up to 1.35 inches thick. The package includes a waterproof bag and cargo net. It suits drivers needing moderate cargo space for SUVs or trucks.

Pros

• 200 lb load capacity
• Adjustable width from 35 to 54 inches
• Includes waterproof bag and cargo net
• Tubular steel construction with rust-resistant coating

Cons

• 200 lb capacity is lower than competitors
• Limited to crossbars under 1.35 inches thick
• No mention of aerodynamic fairing or noise reduction

Good fit if

• You need a roof basket with adjustable width
• You want included storage accessories
• You have narrow crossbars

Skip if

• You plan to carry heavy gear over 200 lbs
• Your crossbars exceed 1.35 inches in thickness
• You require a larger 64-inch footprint

Verdict: WEIZE 54x34x6 Steel Roof Basket offers adjustable width for smaller loads. It fits drivers with narrow crossbars who do not need heavy hauling capacity.

Specifications side by side

Frequently asked questions