Looking Beyond the Pelican BX140R Cargo Case? 6 Alternatives Worth a Look
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Links on this page are affiliate links.
The Pelican BX140R Cargo Case offers extreme durability and weather resistance for protecting gear, tools, or dry food. Its rigid construction and dustproof design make it a strong choice for secure storage. However, you might look for pelican bx140r cargo case alternatives if you need different dimensions, a lower weight, or integrated locking mechanisms that this model lacks. The BX140R also requires a separate roof mount, which adds complexity if you do not already own compatible hardware.
The 6 alternatives listed here were selected because their specifications overlap with the original product’s core function. Each option provides distinct advantages, such as dual-side opening for easier access or higher load capacities for heavier equipment. You can compare sizes, weights, and mounting styles to find a better fit for your specific vehicle and travel needs. This guide focuses strictly on published specs to help you decide which case suits your practical requirements.
Comparing Alternatives to the BX140R
GarveeTech 14 cu ft Dual-Side Opening Roof Box
The GarveeTech 14 cu ft model offers significantly more space than the Pelican BX140R. It measures 62.2 inches long and 31.5 inches wide, compared to the Pelican’s 46 by 24 inches. This larger footprint provides dual-side opening access, which the rigid Pelican case lacks. You gain easier loading from either side of your vehicle. However, it weighs 44.8 pounds, which is heavier than the 35.1-pound Pelican. If you need maximum volume and side access for family trips, this dual-opening design is a practical upgrade over the single-access cargo case.
Eylar SRX-175 Overlanding Cargo Case
The Eylar SRX-175 is a rotomolded case built for waterproof overlanding storage. It matches the Pelican in ruggedness but focuses on complete weather sealing rather than just dustproofing. Its dimensions are 47.2 inches long and 18.4 inches wide, making it narrower than the Pelican’s 24-inch width. This profile may fit tighter roof rack setups. It is also lockable, adding security for valuable gear. You should choose this if you prioritize waterproof integrity and a compact width over the wider storage capacity of the Pelican BX140R. It sacrifices some interior width for enhanced protection.
DNA Motoring 13 cu ft Hard Shell Roof Box
The DNA Motoring 13 cu ft box provides double-side access and tool-free setup. It is larger than the Pelican, measuring 56.3 inches long and 36.8 inches wide. This hard shell design supports up to 110 pounds of load, offering higher capacity than the Pelican’s static storage. It is lockable and designed for car roof mounts. You give up the extreme durability of the Pelican’s rigid case for easier, faster loading from both sides. This option suits drivers who value quick access and higher weight limits over the specialized tool protection of the BX140R.
Relaxcabine 15.5 Cu Ft Dual-Open Roof Box
The Relaxcabine 15.5 Cu Ft box features dual-open access for easy side loading. It measures 58.3 inches long and 35.4 inches wide, providing more surface area than the Pelican’s 46 by 24 inches. It weighs 34.3 pounds, slightly lighter than the Pelican’s 35.1 pounds. The hard shell is lockable for secure storage. You gain convenient side access and a lower weight, which helps with fuel efficiency. However, you trade the Pelican’s specific mounting interface and extreme ruggedness for a general-purpose roof box. Pick this if you want easy access and a lighter profile.
Menabo Mania 320 Liter Roof Box
The Menabo Mania 320 Liter box is much lighter, weighing only 19.8 pounds compared to the Pelican’s 35.1 pounds. It is also narrower at 14.3 inches wide, fitting smaller roof rack crossbars. However, it is taller at 31.5 inches, which may affect vehicle height clearance. It offers 11 cubic feet of space, less than the Pelican’s interior volume. You get quick installation and a low weight, ideal for weekend gear. You lose the wide, flat storage profile of the Pelican. Choose this if you prioritize low weight and narrow compatibility over maximum interior width and rugged tool protection.
VISRACK 13 cu ft Hard-Shell Roof Box
The VISRACK 13 cu ft hard-shell box provides dual-side access and tool-free mounting. It measures 56.3 inches long and 30.3 inches wide, offering a larger footprint than the Pelican. It weighs 27.8 pounds, significantly lighter than the 35.1-pound Pelican case. The hard shell is weather-resistant and lockable. You gain easier access from both sides and a lighter overall weight. You give up the specific rugged, dustproof design of the Pelican BX140R. This option is better for general luggage storage where easy loading and reduced weight are more important than specialized impact protection for tools.
Quick picks
Our 7 picks
Pelican BX140R Cargo Case
Best for: protecting sensitive gear from weather and impact
- Water Resistance
- Weather resistant, dustproof
- Installation
- Cargo Roof Mount (sold separately)
- Dimensions
- 46 x 24 x 11.5 in
- Recommended Use
- Gear, clothing, tools, dry food
- Weight
- 35.1 pounds
View on Amazon: Pelican BX140R Cargo Case Affiliate link
The Pelican BX140R is a rigid cargo case measuring 46 x 24 x 11.5 inches. It weighs 35.1 pounds empty and offers an interior volume of 41.75 x 19 x 8.75 inches. This unit is weather resistant and dustproof, making it suitable for protecting gear, clothing, tools, and dry food. You must purchase the Pelican Cargo Roof Mount separately to install it on your roof rack.
Pros
- Rigid, dustproof construction protects contents from elements
- Heavy-duty lay-flat handles for secure transport
- Includes mounting kit interface plate for rack attachment
- Limited lifetime guarantee covers the case only
Cons
- Requires separate purchase of the Pelican Cargo Roof Mount
- Fixed 11.5-inch height limits compatibility with low-profile racks
- Does not include integrated locking mechanism
Good fit if
- You need a rigid, waterproof container for sensitive gear
- You already own a compatible roof rack mount
- You prioritize impact protection over aerodynamic shape
Skip if
- You want an all-in-one solution with integrated locks
- You require a low-profile box under 12 inches
- You prefer soft-sided or inflatable cargo carriers
Verdict: The Pelican BX140R Rigid Cargo Case is a durable, weather-resistant option for buyers who already have the necessary mounting hardware. It best serves those needing maximum protection for tools or dry food rather than general luggage storage.
GarveeTech 14 cu ft Dual-Side Opening Roof Box
Best for: Dual-side access needs
- Capacity
- 14 cubic feet
- Shell Type
- ABS, hard shell
- Opening
- Dual-side
- Load Capacity
- 165 lbs
- Water Resistance
- Waterproof
- Security
- 2 keys and 2 straps
View on Amazon: GarveeTech 14 cu ft Dual-Side Opening Roof Box Affiliate link
This GarveeTech roof box offers 14 cubic feet of storage with dual-side opening for convenient access. The ABS shell is waterproof and UV-resistant, protecting cargo from weather. It measures 62.2 x 31.5 x 13.4 inches and supports up to 165 lbs. You get two keys and straps for security. It fits all vehicles with roof racks.
Pros
- Dual-side opening for easy access
- 14 cubic feet capacity
- Waterproof ABS construction
- Supports 165 lbs load
Cons
- Heavier at 44.8 lbs
- Limited to two keys included
- Only one height option available
Good fit if
- You need access from both sides
- You carry bulky gear
- You want waterproof protection
Skip if
- You prefer lightweight carriers
- You need more than 14 cubic feet
- You have no roof rack
Verdict: GarveeTech 14 Cu Ft Dual-Side Roof Box suits those who prioritize side access and weather protection. It is a solid choice for families needing secure, spacious storage on road trips.
Eylar SRX-175 Overlanding Cargo Case
Best for: Waterproof overlanding gear storage
- Capacity
- 175L
- Shell Type
- rotomolded hard case
- Water Resistance
- 100% Waterproof
- Dimensions
- 47.2"L x 18.4"W x 17.9"H
- Vehicle Type
- Truck
- Recommended Use
- Camping
View on Amazon: Eylar SRX-175 Overlanding Cargo Case Affiliate link
The Eylar SRX-175 is a 175L rotomolded cargo case designed for truck beds and roof racks. It measures 47.2 inches long and features a 100% waterproof seal with a heavy-duty rubber gasket. The unit weighs 38.5 lbs and includes a hands-free gas strut lid. It offers four lockable latches and two removable interior trays for organized storage. This case suits overlanders and campers needing rugged, weatherproof gear protection.
Pros
- 175L capacity with 47.2-inch length
- 100% waterproof rubber gasket seal
- Rotomolded hard shell construction
- Hands-free gas strut lid
- Four lockable padlock-compatible latches
Cons
- 38.5 lb weight is heavy for manual handling
- Padlock sold separately
- No integrated locking mechanism without external padlock
Good fit if
- You need 100% waterproof protection for sensitive gear
- You want a rotomolded case for truck bed use
- You prefer a hands-free lid for loading
Skip if
- You need a lighter case under 30 lbs
- You require an integrated lock system
- You have a small SUV with limited roof width
Verdict: Eylar SRX-175 175L Rotomolded Case provides maximum weather protection and volume for overlanding trips. It fits buyers who prioritize rugged durability and waterproofing over lightweight portability.
DNA Motoring 13 cu ft Hard Shell Roof Box
Best for: moderate storage with double-side access
- Capacity
- 13 Cubic Feet
- Shell Type
- Hard Shell, ABS
- Opening
- Double side
- Load Capacity
- 110 lbs
- Water Resistance
- Weatherproof
- Security
- Security locking system with keys
View on Amazon: DNA Motoring 13 cu ft Hard Shell Roof Box Affiliate link
This DNA Motoring rooftop cargo box offers 13 cubic feet of storage with a 110 lb load capacity. It features a hard ABS shell and double-side opening for easy access. The unit requires cross bars and installs without tools. It is a practical option for those needing moderate extra space and weather protection for their gear.
Pros
- 13 cubic feet internal storage capacity
- Double-side opening for convenient loading
- No-tool assembly installation process
- Hard ABS shell with weatherproof design
Cons
- 110 lb load limit is lower than many competitors
- Requires cross bars for mounting
- 16.25 inch height may affect clearance
Good fit if
- You need double-side access for bulky items
- You want a no-tool assembly solution
- You have cross bars and moderate storage needs
Skip if
- You require a load capacity above 110 lbs
- You do not have cross bars installed
- You need a slim profile under 16 inches
Verdict: DNA Motoring 13 Cu Ft Hard Shell Roof Box provides reliable double-side access and tool-free setup for drivers with cross bars. It suits those prioritizing easy loading over maximum weight capacity.
Relaxcabine 15.5 Cu Ft Dual-Open Roof Box
Best for: side access and easy mounting
- Capacity
- 15.5 cu ft
- Shell Type
- ABS and PMMA hard shell
- Opening
- dual-side
- Load Capacity
- 130 lbs
- Water Resistance
- waterproof, weather-resistant
- Security
- built-in locking system
View on Amazon: Relaxcabine 15.5 Cu Ft Dual-Open Roof Box Affiliate link
The Relaxcabine offers 15.5 cubic feet of storage in a hard shell made of ABS and PMMA. It weighs 34.3 pounds and supports up to 130 lbs of gear. The dual-side opening lid allows access from either side of your vehicle. It installs tool-free on most crossbars. This box suits families needing convenient, secure rooftop storage for camping or road trips.
Pros
- 15.5 cubic feet capacity
- Dual-side opening lid
- Tool-free installation
- Built-in locking system
- ABS and PMMA hard shell
Cons
- 130 lbs load limit is lower than some competitors
- 34.3 pounds weight adds roof load
- No mention of aerodynamic design for noise reduction
Good fit if
- You need side access for tight parking spots
- You want tool-free mounting on existing crossbars
- You carry bulky gear up to 130 lbs
Skip if
- You require more than 15.5 cubic feet of space
- You need a load capacity exceeding 130 lbs
- You prefer a lighter unit under 30 pounds
Verdict: Relaxcabine 15.5 Cu Ft Dual-Open Roof Box fits drivers who prioritize easy side access and straightforward installation over maximum load capacity or aerodynamic efficiency.
Menabo Mania 320 Liter Roof Box
Best for: secure storage with quick installation
- Capacity
- 320 liters/11 cubic feet
- Load Capacity
- 50 kg or 110 lbs
- Installation
- quick fixing system
- Vehicle Compatibility
- Compatible with all roof carriers
- Dimensions
- 55 x 14.3 x 31.5 in
- Weight
- 19.8 pounds
View on Amazon: Menabo Mania 320 Liter Roof Box Affiliate link
The Menabo Mania roof box offers 11 cubic feet of storage in a glossy black shell. It measures 55 x 14.3 x 31.5 inches and weighs 19.8 pounds. The unit supports a maximum load of 110 pounds. Its patented double snap closure locks securely. The quick fixing system installs on all roof carriers, making it a practical option for standard luggage transport.
Pros
- 11 cubic feet (320 liters) capacity
- Patented double snap closure locks securely
- Quick fixing system fits all roof carriers
- Supports up to 110 lbs load
Cons
- 11 cubic feet is smaller than the 13-15.5 cubic feet options on this list
- 14.3 inches width is narrower than typical wide cargo boxes
- No mention of side-opening access in specifications
Good fit if
- You need a compact box for shorter trips
- You prefer a secure snap-lock mechanism
- You have standard crossbars or roof racks
Skip if
- You require over 13 cubic feet of space
- You need to access items from the side
- You plan to carry heavy loads over 110 lbs
Verdict: Menabo Mania 11 Cu Ft Roof Box fits drivers who prioritize secure locking and easy installation over maximum volume. It is ideal for weekend gear rather than full moving loads.
VISRACK 13 cu ft Hard-Shell Roof Box
Best for: Dual-side access and tool-free mounting
- Capacity
- 13 cu ft
- Shell Type
- ABS and PC hard shell
- Opening
- Dual-side
- Load Capacity
- 130 lbs (50 kg)
- Security
- Central locking system
- Installation
- Tool-free U-brackets
View on Amazon: VISRACK 13 cu ft Hard-Shell Roof Box Affiliate link
The VISRACK roof box offers 13 cubic feet of storage with a 130-pound load capacity. Its hard shell, made from ABS and PC, protects gear from weather. You get dual-side opening for easy access and a central locking system for security. It mounts tool-free to bars up to 3 inches wide. This unit suits families needing reliable, secure cargo space for road trips.
Pros
- 13 cubic feet capacity with 130 lbs load limit
- Dual-side opening lid for flexible access
- Central locking system secures all mounting points
- Tool-free installation with adjustable U-brackets
- Hard shell construction resists impact and weather
Cons
- 13 cubic feet capacity is smaller than the Menabo 320L option
- 130 lbs load capacity is lower than the DNA MOTORING 110 lbs limit
- No mention of integrated lock core or key storage
Good fit if
- You need dual-side access for street parking
- You want tool-free mounting on existing bars
- You require a hard shell for weather protection
Skip if
- You need more than 13 cubic feet of space
- You require a load capacity over 130 lbs
- You prefer a model with an integrated lock core
Verdict: VISRACK 13 Cu Ft Hard-Shell Roof Box provides secure, weather-resistant storage for users who prioritize easy access and straightforward installation over maximum volume.
Specifications side by side
| Spec | Pelican BX140R Cargo Case | GarveeTech 14 cu ft Dual-Side Opening Roof Box | Eylar SRX-175 Overlanding Cargo Case | DNA Motoring 13 cu ft Hard Shell Roof Box | Relaxcabine 15.5 Cu Ft Dual-Open Roof Box | Menabo Mania 320 Liter Roof Box | VISRACK 13 cu ft Hard-Shell Roof Box |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Capacity | not stated | 14 cubic feet | 175L | 13 Cubic Feet | 15.5 cu ft | 320 liters/11 cubic feet | 13 cu ft |
| Shell Type | not stated | ABS, hard shell | rotomolded hard case | Hard Shell, ABS | ABS and PMMA hard shell | not stated | ABS and PC hard shell |
| Opening | not stated | Dual-side | not stated | Double side | dual-side | not stated | Dual-side |
| Load Capacity | not stated | 165 lbs | not stated | 110 lbs | 130 lbs | 50 kg or 110 lbs | 130 lbs (50 kg) |
| Water Resistance | Weather resistant, dustproof | Waterproof | 100% Waterproof | Weatherproof | waterproof, weather-resistant | not stated | not stated |
| Security | not stated | 2 keys and 2 straps | not stated | Security locking system with keys | built-in locking system | not stated | Central locking system |
| Installation | Cargo Roof Mount (sold separately) | not stated | not stated | No tool assembly | tool-free | quick fixing system | Tool-free U-brackets |
| Vehicle Compatibility | not stated | Vehicles with roof rack | not stated | Fits vehicles with cross bars only | crossbars | Compatible with all roof carriers | Crossbars up to 3 in wide |
| Dimensions | 46 x 24 x 11.5 in | 62.2 x 31.5 x 13.4 in | 47.2"L x 18.4"W x 17.9"H | 56.3" L x 36.8" W x 16.25" H | 58.3 x 35.4 x 13 in | 55 x 14.3 x 31.5 in | 55.91" L x 29.53" W x 14.96" H |
| Recommended Use | Gear, clothing, tools, dry food | Luggage | not stated | not stated | camping | not stated | Bulky luggage |
| Vehicle Type | not stated | not stated | Truck | Car | not stated | not stated | not stated |
| Mount Type | not stated | Roof Mount | not stated | Roof Mount | not stated | not stated | not stated |
| Lockable | not stated | not stated | Lockable | Lockable | Lockable | not stated | Lockable |
| Weight | 35.1 pounds | 44.8 pounds | not stated | not stated | 34.3 pounds | 19.8 pounds | 27.8 pounds |
| Size | Cargo Case | 14 cubic feet | not stated | 13 cu. ft.-16.25" H | 15.5 Cu Ft Black | 320 L | Diamond Black-13Cubic |
| Color | Black | Black | Black | Textured Black | Black | Black | Diamond Black-13Cubic |
| Model | BX140-BLK | nncczujx4eU50hm4c2vYzgYDb1 | SR00011 | PT-ZTL-8188 | Black Cargo Box-61 | M000036100000 | D56 |
If you need a smaller exterior footprint, review pelican cargo case bx55s alternatives to compare capacity and dimensions.
Frequently asked questions
Which roof box offers the most storage volume?
The Relaxcabine 15.5 Cu Ft Dual-Open Roof Box provides the largest capacity on this list. It measures 58.3 inches long and 35.4 inches wide. This generous size suits drivers who need maximum space for gear. The dual-opening design allows easy access from both sides of the vehicle.
What is the lightest roof box available?
The Menabo Mania 320 Liter Roof Box is the lightest option at 19.8 pounds. Its compact 11 cubic feet capacity makes it ideal for weekend trips. The low weight simplifies installation and removal. It prioritizes secure locking and ease of use over carrying heavy loads.
Which case is best for waterproof overlanding?
The Eylar SRX-175 Overlanding Cargo Case is designed for rugged, waterproof storage. It features a rotomolded construction for maximum durability. This case fits buyers who prioritize weather protection over lightweight portability. It is lockable and recommended for camping and truck use.
How does the Pelican BX140R compare in weight?
The Pelican BX140R weighs 35.1 pounds. It is heavier than the Menabo Mania but lighter than the GarveeTech 14 cu ft model. Its rigid construction focuses on protecting sensitive gear. You must provide your own mounting hardware for installation.
Which roof box supports the highest weight capacity?
The DNA Motoring 13 cu ft Hard Shell Roof Box supports a load capacity of 110 lb. It features double-side access and tool-free setup. This model suits drivers who prioritize easy loading and secure storage over maximum volume. It is compatible with most roof crossbars.
What are the dimensions of the GarveeTech model?
The GarveeTech 14 cu ft Dual-Side Opening Roof Box measures 62.2 inches long, 31.5 inches wide, and 13.4 inches high. It weighs 44.8 pounds. The large footprint provides ample space for families. The dual-side opening allows convenient access from either side of the vehicle.
Which option is best for tool-free installation?
The DNA Motoring and VISRACK models both offer tool-free mounting. The DNA Motoring 13 cu ft box features a hard shell and lockable design. The VISRACK 13 cu ft box also provides dual-side access. Both prioritize straightforward installation for users who want quick setup.