Malone MegaWing V-Style Kayak Carrier or Malone Downloader Folding J-Style Kayak? Which Malone Model to Buy
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Links on this page are affiliate links.
The malone megawing v style kayak carrier vs downloader folding j style comparison highlights two distinct approaches to roof-top kayak transport. Both models use Malone’s JAWZ mounting hardware for tool-free installation on various crossbar shapes. They also include bow and stern tie-downs for highway security. The main difference lies in their design and capacity. The MegaWing offers a rigid V-style cradle for heavier boats, while the Downloader provides a folding J-style design with a built-in boarding ramp for easier loading.
Key differences
| Aspect | Malone MegaWing V-Style Kayak Carrier | Malone Downloader Folding J-Style Kayak Carrier |
|---|---|---|
| Shell Type | V-Style | J-Style |
| Load Capacity | 150 lb | 75 lb |
| Folding Mechanism | Not listed | Folds down for clearance |
| Boarding Aid | Not listed | Built-in boarding ramp |
| Dimensions (LxWxH) | 28 x 7.75 x 6 inches | 21 x 10 x 8 inches |
Which one should you choose?
Choose Malone MegaWing V-Style Kayak Carrier if
- You transport a single kayak that weighs up to 150 lb
- You prefer a rigid V-style cradle for better kayak stability
- You need a low-profile design to reduce wind noise
Choose Malone Downloader Folding J-Style Kayak Carrier if
- You need to fold the carrier up for garage storage
- You want a built-in ramp to make loading easier
- Your kayak weighs 75 lb or less
Verdict: Choose the MegaWing if you prioritize higher weight capacity and a secure, rigid V-style hold for larger kayaks. Select the Downloader if you value easy loading via the integrated ramp and the convenience of a folding design for storage.
Malone V-Style vs J-Style Carrier
Load Capacity
The Malone MegaWing V-Style Kayak Carrier supports a maximum load of 150 lb. This heavy-duty rating makes it suitable for larger, heavier boats that require robust support. In contrast, the Malone Downloader Folding J-Style Kayak Carrier has a lower load capacity of 75 lb. This limit is better suited for standard, lighter kayaks. If you transport a large or heavy vessel, the MegaWing provides the necessary strength. The Downloader is adequate for typical recreational kayaks but may not handle heavier loads safely. You should choose the MegaWing if weight capacity is your primary concern.
Shell Design
The MegaWing features a reinforced V-style design with two holders to cradle a single kayak. This shape distributes weight across the hull, which is ideal for protecting the boat. The Downloader uses a J-style configuration with built-in boarding ramp features for easier loading. While the J-style is convenient for lifting, the V-style offers a more secure cradle for heavy loads. The MegaWing’s design is engineered specifically for larger boats, whereas the Downloader prioritizes ease of access. Your choice depends on whether you value secure cradling or quick loading mechanics.
Foldability
The Downloader includes fold-down technology to increase overhead clearance when not in use. This feature allows you to raise the carrier out of the way, which is helpful for garage storage or low-clearance areas. The MegaWing does not fold; it maintains a fixed, streamlined profile. Its dimensions are 6 inches wide, 27.5 inches long, and 4.5 inches high. While the MegaWing is low-profile, it remains fixed on the roof. If you frequently need to clear space on your roof rack, the Downloader’s folding mechanism is a significant practical advantage.
Weight
The Malone MegaWing V-Style Kayak Carrier weighs 11.9 pounds. This is slightly heavier than the Downloader, which weighs 10 pounds. The difference is small, but the Downloader is lighter overall. The MegaWing’s extra weight comes from its reinforced V-style construction designed for higher loads. For most users, this 1.9-pound difference will not impact daily use. However, if you frequently remove the carrier from the roof, the lighter Downloader may be easier to handle. Both units are manageable, but the Downloader has a slight edge in portability.
Dimensions
The MegaWing measures 28 inches in length, 7.75 inches in width, and 6 inches in height. The Downloader measures 21 inches in length, 10 inches in width, and 8 inches in height. The MegaWing is longer but narrower and shorter in height. The Downloader is more compact in length but taller and wider. The MegaWing’s low height of 6 inches helps reduce wind noise and improves garage clearance. The Downloader’s height of 8 inches may catch more wind. You should consider your vehicle’s width and the carrier’s footprint when deciding which fits your roof rack best.
Which Malone Kayak Carrier Fits Your Needs
Heavy kayak owners needing high capacity
You need to transport larger boats. The Malone MegaWing supports up to 150 lb. Its reinforced V-style design handles heavy loads safely. The carrier measures 28 inches long and weighs 11.9 pounds. This model ensures secure transport for heavier gear without compromising stability on the roof.
Drivers needing extra garage clearance
Overhead space is tight. The Downloader folds down to save height. It stands 19.5 inches tall but collapses for storage. This folding J-style design helps you fit into low garages easily. It also includes an boarding ramp for easier loading, making daily use more convenient for you.
Light kayak users wanting simple setup
Your boat weighs under 75 lb. The Downloader handles this weight easily. It features oversized padding to protect your craft. The JAWZ hardware installs without tools on most crossbars. This model is lighter at 10 pounds, making it a practical choice for lighter kayaks and quick trips.
The products compared
Malone MegaWing V-Style Kayak Carrier
Best for: heavy kayaks up to 150 lb
- Load Capacity
- 150 lb
- Size
- One Size
- Use
- Kayak
- Dimensions
- 28 × 7.75 × 6 inches
- Weight
- 11.9 pounds
View on Amazon: Malone MegaWing V-Style Kayak Carrier Affiliate link
This is a heavy-duty V-style kayak carrier designed for larger, heavier boats. It supports up to 150 lb and features corrosion-resistant nylon construction. The unit includes universal JAWZ mounting hardware for round, square, or oval crossbars. It measures 28 inches long and weighs 11.9 pounds. You get 15-foot cam buckle straps and tie-downs for secure transport. This model suits those needing high capacity and durable materials.
Pros
- 150 lb load capacity for heavy kayaks
- Corrosion-resistant high-strength nylon build
- Universal JAWZ mounting for various bars
- Includes 15' cam buckle straps and tie-downs
Cons
- Heavier at 11.9 pounds compared to folding alternatives
- Larger footprint at 28 inches long
- Requires manual tightening of straps
Good fit if
- You carry kayaks over 100 lb
- You need corrosion-resistant materials for saltwater use
- You have fixed crossbars and want a permanent mount
Skip if
- You need a folding design for easy storage
- You prioritize lightweight carriers under 10 pounds
- You want a low-profile V-style for very narrow garages
Verdict: Malone MegaWing V-Style Kayak Carrier is a robust option for transporting heavy kayaks up to 150 lb. It fits buyers who need durable, corrosion-resistant hardware and do not require a folding mechanism.
Malone Downloader Folding J-Style Kayak Carrier
Best for: Light kayaks and compact storage needs
- Load Capacity
- 75 lb
- Vehicle Type
- Car
- Size
- One Size
- Use
- Kayak
- Dimensions
- 21 × 10 × 8 inches
- Weight
- 10 pounds
View on Amazon: Malone Downloader Folding J-Style Kayak Carrier Affiliate link
This Malone Downloader is a folding J-style kayak carrier designed for easy loading and storage. It features built-in boarding ramps and oversized padding to protect your boat. The unit supports a load capacity of 75 lb and weighs 10 pounds. It includes JAWZ mounting hardware compatible with round, square, and oval cross rails. This model is suitable for car owners needing a compact solution for transporting kayaks.
Pros
- Folding design increases overhead clearance
- Built-in boarding ramp for easy loading
- Oversized padding protects boat during transport
- JAWZ hardware fits round, square, and oval rails
- Includes 60mm and 70mm mounting bolts
Cons
- 75 lb load capacity is lower than typical V-style carriers
- 10 lb weight adds bulk to roof rack
- Single unit requires manual bow and stern lines
Good fit if
- You need compact storage when not in use
- You have oval or square cross rails
- You want easy kayak loading assistance
Skip if
- You carry kayaks heavier than 75 lb
- You prefer a rigid V-style design
- You want a single-point mounting system
Verdict: Malone Downloader Folding J-Style Kayak Carrier fits drivers who prioritize low-profile storage and easy loading over maximum weight capacity. It is ideal for lighter kayaks and those with non-round roof racks.
Specifications side by side
| Spec | Malone MegaWing V-Style Kayak Carrier | Malone Downloader Folding J-Style Kayak Carrier |
|---|---|---|
| Load Capacity | 150 lb | 75 lb |
| Vehicle Type | not stated | Car |
| Size | One Size | One Size |
| Use | Kayak | Kayak |
| Dimensions | 28 × 7.75 × 6 inches | 21 × 10 × 8 inches |
| Weight | 11.9 pounds | 10 pounds |
| Color | black | Multi |
| Model | MPG207 | MPG114MD |
Frequently asked questions
Can the Malone MegaWing hold a heavy kayak?
Yes, it supports up to 150 lb. This high load capacity makes it suitable for larger and heavier boats. The robust V-style design ensures stable transport. It is an ideal choice if you regularly carry substantial watercraft that require durable support on your roof rack.
Does the Downloader fold for storage?
Yes, the Malone Downloader features a folding mechanism. This design allows for low-profile storage when not in use. It is particularly useful for drivers who prioritize compactness. The folding action helps keep the carrier out of the way during off-seasons or daily commutes.
Which carrier is lighter to carry?
The Malone Downloader weighs 10 pounds. The MegaWing is slightly heavier at 11.9 pounds. While both are manageable, the Downloader offers a lighter option. This difference may matter if you frequently remove the carriers from your vehicle for storage or transport.
Are both models suitable for crossbars?
Yes, both use Malone’s JAWZ mounting hardware. This system allows for tool-free installation on various crossbar shapes. You do not need special adapters for standard roof racks. The hardware ensures a secure fit regardless of whether your bars are round or square.
What is the length of each carrier?
The MegaWing measures 28 inches in length. The Downloader is shorter at 21 inches. This size difference affects how much roof space each unit occupies. The MegaWing provides a longer support base, while the Downloader offers a more compact footprint for your vehicle.
Is the MegaWing good for corrosion resistance?
Yes, it includes durable, corrosion-resistant hardware. This feature is important for long-term use in various weather conditions. The construction ensures that the carrier remains reliable over time. You can trust the hardware to withstand exposure to moisture and road salt without degrading quickly.
Does the Downloader work with non-round racks?
Yes, it is ideal for non-round roof racks. The JAWZ mounting system adapts to different bar shapes. This versatility makes it a flexible choice for many vehicles. You can install it on square, round, or aerodynamic crossbars without needing additional adapters or modifications.