Malone SeaWing Saddle Style Universal or Malone J-Pro 2 J-Style Universal? Which Malone Model to Buy
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Links on this page are affiliate links.
This comparison of the malone seawing saddle style universal vs j pro 2 j style universal helps you choose the right kayak carrier. Both Malone models use the universal Jawz mounting system for round, square, or oval cross rails without tools. They both include bow and stern tie-down straps for highway security. The main difference lies in their construction and capacity. The SeaWing uses a low-profile nylon design with a 70-pound limit, while the J-Pro 2 features a steel frame. You need to decide which build and size suit your vehicle and kayak best.
Key differences
| Aspect | Malone SeaWing Kayak Carrier | Malone J-Pro 2 J-Style Kayak Carrier |
|---|---|---|
| Shell Type | Nylon V-style cradles | E-coated steel frame |
| Load Capacity | 70 lb | not listed |
| Width | 8 inches | 16 inches |
| Length | 28 inches | 24 inches |
| Weight | 11.6 pounds | 11.5 pounds |
Which one should you choose?
Choose Malone SeaWing Kayak Carrier if
- You want a lower profile to reduce wind resistance
- You need a specified 70 lb load capacity
- You prefer a nylon construction that flexes gently
Choose Malone J-Pro 2 J-Style Kayak Carrier if
- You prefer a durable steel frame construction
- You want a narrower unit for tighter roof space
- You value a limited lifetime manufacturer's warranty
Verdict: Choose the SeaWing if you prioritize a low-profile design and a clear 70-pound load capacity for recreational kayaks. Opt for the J-Pro 2 if you prefer a steel frame construction and a narrower footprint. Both models secure your kayak effectively with included tie-downs and universal mounting hardware.
Malone SeaWing vs J-Pro 2 Specs
Load capacity
The Malone SeaWing Saddle Style Universal supports a maximum load of 70 pounds. This rating applies to the weight of the kayak it holds. The Malone J-Pro 2 J-Style Universal does not list a specific weight capacity in its provided specifications. Because the SeaWing publishes a clear limit, you can plan your load with confidence. The J-Pro 2 relies on general construction claims rather than a stated number. For buyers who need to know the exact weight limit before purchase, the SeaWing provides the necessary data. The J-Pro 2 leaves this detail unspecified in the available product data.
Shell type
The Malone SeaWing Saddle Style Universal features a V-style cradle design. This shape flexes gently to support the kayak hull while reducing wind resistance during travel. The Malone J-Pro 2 J-Style Universal uses a J-style configuration. This design typically secures the kayak by the stern or bow, holding it vertically or at an angle. The SeaWing offers a low-profile saddle that lays flat on the roof. The J-Pro 2 offers a different holding mechanism that may suit different kayak shapes. Your choice depends on whether you prefer a cradle or a J-hook style.
Build material
The Malone J-Pro 2 J-Style Universal is constructed from E-coated, corrosion-resistant steel. This metal construction is described as holding up to years of abuse. The Malone SeaWing Saddle Style Universal is built with tough nylon and corrosion-resistant components. Nylon is a durable plastic that does not rust. Steel is heavier but offers rigid strength. The SeaWing uses a combination of materials for weather resistance. The J-Pro 2 relies entirely on treated steel for its structure. Both designs aim for long-term durability in various weather conditions.
Dimensions
The Malone SeaWing Saddle Style Universal measures 28 inches in length, 8 inches in width, and 6 inches in height. It weighs 11.6 pounds. The Malone J-Pro 2 J-Style Universal measures 24 inches in length, 16 inches in width, and 6 inches in height. It weighs 11.5 pounds. The SeaWing is longer but narrower, taking up less roof width. The J-Pro 2 is shorter but wider, occupying more space across the rails. Both units have the same height profile. The SeaWing is slightly heavier by 0.1 pounds. These size differences affect how much room remains on your roof for other gear.
Security features
Both kayak carriers include bow and stern tie-downs for added security. The Malone SeaWing Saddle Style Universal includes heavy-duty straps to prevent kayak movement at highway speeds. The Malone J-Pro 2 J-Style Universal also comes with bow and stern safety tie-downs. It specifically includes two 12-foot cam buckle straps and mounting bolts in 60mm and 70mm sizes. The J-Pro 2 provides specific strap lengths and bolt options in its feature list. The SeaWing mentions heavy-duty straps without listing specific lengths or bolt sizes. Both ensure your kayak is secured during transport.
Warranty
The Malone J-Pro 2 J-Style Universal includes a limited lifetime manufacturer's warranty. This coverage is explicitly stated in its features list. The Malone SeaWing Saddle Style Universal does not mention a warranty in its provided specifications. While the SeaWing is built with durable materials, the absence of warranty data means you cannot confirm the coverage terms from this information. The J-Pro 2 offers a clear lifetime guarantee. For buyers who prioritize long-term protection and manufacturer support, the J-Pro 2 provides this benefit in its published details.
Choose the Right Malone Kayak Carrier
Driver needing low wind resistance
The SeaWing features a V-style cradle design that flexes to support the hull while reducing wind resistance. Its low-profile shape improves fuel efficiency and stability at highway speeds. The compact dimensions of 27.5 by 6 by 4.5 inches take up minimal roof space, leaving room for other gear.
User prioritizing corrosion resistance
The J-Pro 2 is constructed from E-coated steel, offering strong protection against rust and corrosion. It includes a limited lifetime manufacturer's warranty for added peace of mind. The silver finish and durable steel build make it suitable for long-term use in harsh weather conditions, including coastal salt air.
Owner with oval cross rails
Both models use the universal Jawz mounting system for round, square, or oval rails. The SeaWing installs quickly with a no-tool mid-point mounting system. It includes heavy-duty bow and stern tie-down straps to prevent kayak movement. This setup ensures secure transport without requiring additional adapters or complex tools.
The products compared
Malone SeaWing Kayak Carrier
Best for: standard recreational kayaks on universal roof rails
- Load Capacity
- 70 lb
- Vehicle Type
- Car
- Use
- Kayak
- Dimensions
- 28 × 8 × 6 inches
- Weight
- 11.6 pounds
View on Amazon: Malone SeaWing Kayak Carrier Affiliate link
The Malone SeaWing Saddle Style is a universal kayak carrier designed for cars. It features a V-style cradle that flexes to support hulls while reducing wind resistance. The unit measures 28 inches long, 8 inches wide, and weighs 11.6 pounds. It supports up to 70 pounds and includes bow and stern tie-downs. The Jawz mounting system fits round, square, and oval rails without tools. This compact design leaves room for other gear on your roof.
Pros
- 70 lb load capacity for most recreational kayaks
- Universal Jawz mounting fits round, square, and oval rails
- Includes heavy-duty bow and stern safety tie-downs
- Low-profile V-style design reduces wind resistance
Cons
- 11.6 lb weight is heavier than some single-point carriers
- 70 lb limit may not suit very large or heavy kayaks
- No mention of integrated locking mechanisms for security
Good fit if
- You need a universal fit for various roof rail shapes
- You want included tie-downs for added highway safety
- You prefer a compact unit that saves roof space
Skip if
- You require a capacity higher than 70 pounds
- You need a carrier with integrated locking features
- You prefer a significantly lighter unit under 10 pounds
Verdict: The Malone SeaWing Saddle Style 70 lb Kayak Carrier is a solid choice for drivers with universal roof rails who prioritize secure tie-downs and a low-profile design. It suits those carrying standard recreational kayaks under 70 pounds.
Malone J-Pro 2 J-Style Kayak Carrier
Best for: Secure single kayak transport on various rails
- Vehicle Type
- Car
- Use
- Kayak
- Dimensions
- 24 × 16 × 6 inches
- Weight
- 11.5 pounds
View on Amazon: Malone J-Pro 2 J-Style Kayak Carrier Affiliate link
The Malone J-Pro 2 is a universal J-style kayak carrier designed for secure transport. It measures 24 inches long, 16 inches wide, and 6 inches high, weighing 11.5 pounds. The E-coated steel construction resists corrosion. It fits round, square, and oval cross rails using universal mounting hardware. This model includes bow and stern tie-downs for stability. It suits drivers needing a durable, simple solution for single kayak transport.
Pros
- E-coated corrosion-resistant steel construction
- Fits round, square, and factory oval cross rails
- Includes bow and stern safety tie-downs
- Comes with two 12-foot cam buckle straps
Cons
- Heavier build at 11.5 pounds
- No integrated locking mechanism mentioned
- Requires separate purchase of cross rails
Good fit if
- You need a universal fit for various rail shapes
- You want included safety tie-downs for stability
- You prefer durable steel construction over plastic
Skip if
- You require a lightweight aluminum option
- You need integrated locks for security
- You already own compatible mounting hardware
Verdict: The Malone J-Pro 2 J-Style Kayak Carrier offers solid steel durability and universal compatibility for secure transport. It fits drivers who prioritize corrosion resistance and included tie-downs over lightweight materials.
Specifications side by side
| Spec | Malone SeaWing Kayak Carrier | Malone J-Pro 2 J-Style Kayak Carrier |
|---|---|---|
| Load Capacity | 70 lb | not stated |
| Vehicle Type | Car | Car |
| Use | Kayak | Kayak |
| Dimensions | 28 × 8 × 6 inches | 24 × 16 × 6 inches |
| Weight | 11.6 pounds | 11.5 pounds |
| Size | MPG107MD | not stated |
| Model | MPG107MD | MPG117MD |
| Color | not stated | silver |
Frequently asked questions
Which Malone carrier is lighter?
The Malone J-Pro 2 is slightly lighter. It weighs 11.5 pounds. The SeaWing Saddle Style weighs 11.6 pounds. The difference is minimal. You likely will not notice the weight change while loading your vehicle. Both units are easy to handle.
How wide is each kayak carrier?
The SeaWing Saddle Style is 8 inches wide. The J-Pro 2 is 16 inches wide. The SeaWing has a narrower footprint. This design helps reduce wind drag. The J-Pro 2 is wider but still fits standard roof rails securely.
Do these carriers include tie-down straps?
Yes, both models include necessary tie-downs. The SeaWing uses straps to secure the kayak to the cradle. The J-Pro 2 also comes with included straps. You do not need to buy separate straps for basic operation. Check the box contents for exact strap types.
Which model is better for fuel efficiency?
The SeaWing Saddle Style is likely better for fuel efficiency. It has a low-profile V-style design. This shape reduces wind resistance. The J-Pro 2 is wider and taller. It may create more drag. Choose the SeaWing if you drive long distances frequently.
Can I use these on oval rails?
Yes, both carriers work with oval rails. They use the universal Jawz mounting system. This system adapts to round, square, or oval crossbars. You do not need special adapters. Ensure your roof rails are compatible with the Jawz clamp before purchasing either model.
Which carrier is more durable?
The J-Pro 2 is built for durability. It features solid steel construction. This material resists corrosion well. The SeaWing uses a different design focused on low profile. If you prioritize ruggedness and corrosion resistance, the J-Pro 2 is the stronger choice for heavy use.
What is the height difference between them?
Both carriers have the same height. The SeaWing is 6 inches tall. The J-Pro 2 is also 6 inches tall. The height does not differ between these two models. The main difference lies in their width and overall profile shape on the roof.